"A Pinch of Salt" / Christians Interested in Anarchism
"You are the salt of the earth" Matthew 5:13
Issue Nine Donation appreciated / Free to prisoners
Celebrate freedom / Destroy the Prison Systems of the World
"A Pinch of Salt" Spring 1988 Number Nine
c/o 24 South Road, Hockley, BIRMINGHAM B18
Telephone 021 551 1679
John Habgood, Archbishop of York, attacked Clause 28 as "a
dangerous threat to civil liberties*' in a speech he made
in the House of Lords: "Once the principle is there that the
government can control the ideas which are read and
published, we cannot tell how those who follow us will use
those powers". Confining himself to the issue of civil
liberties seemed a safe bet, as an assertion of lesbian and
gay rights would have been a bit contentious - the issue
and status of homosexuals being a great issue of debate
within the Church of England.
The Bishop of Ripen, David Young, made explicit his barring
of active homosexuals from joining his clergy and his
intention to discipline those already in his Diocese. In
ammending a motion in the General Synod of the CofE from
calling for expulsion of unrepentant homosexual clergy to
describing homosexual genital acts as "falling short of the
Christian ideal", great fears of moral liberalism, were
induced and the Sun roared "Pulpit Poofs Can Stay". But, the
Bishops showed their truer colours by saying that they
didn't vote for disciplinary measures because they already
existed.
Clause 28 could be yet another link in the chain of
reactionary and repressive legislation introduced by
this government. Formerly Clause 27 (just to confuse
you) it is intended to outlaw the promotion of
homosexuality by schools and local councils. This
amendment to the Local Government Bill will effectivly
suppress gay life, arts and entertainment.
There is widespread concern that gay help and informat¬
ion services, such as Lesbian and Gay Switchboard who
are reliant on financial support from the government
and local councils will be forced out of existence due
to a curtailment of those funds by an authority which
deems them to be "promoting " homosexuality.
Viscount Falkland(I) articulates the concern of many:
"The word"promote" in the amendment to the Local
Government Bill is so broad that local authorities will
not want to put their money behind anything that smacks
of homosexuality. This is the back door to censorship."
(Capital Gay 29/1/88)
The repurcussions could be extremely oppressive - the
National Council for Civil Liberties has said that gay
clubs and discos were liable to lose their li cences -
which have to be renewed annually by the local council.
Theatres too may have to stop presenting plays which
show homosexual life in a favourable light.
Libraries too will be affected as books such as
James Balwin f s "Giovanni's Room" and even Alice Walker's
"The Colour Purple" will be removed from the bookshelves,
thereby restricting the freedom of those who cannot
afford the "freedom of choice" to go out and buy the
books they want to read.
Gay and lesbian teachers are those most at risk from
Clause 28. The government fears that children are
corrupted "in the formative years" by dicussion of gay
lifestyles in the classroom, which could be seen by
some as "promotion" with the intent (in the words of
the Duke of Norfolk) to perpetrate "the sinister corru¬
ption of youth by promoting homosexuality". So, by
explaining alternatives , or by even counselling a
student a teacher could be subjected to a disciplinary
hearing, sacking or even prosecution.
Once more the government is attempting to curtail a
basic human right, this time the right to express our
sexuality. Resist their laws , express in love.
So, the apparent tolerance is a bigoted "liberalism", and
still few Christians stand up for lesbian and gay rights.
The trend seems to be that to be homosexual is OK, but to
be "active" isn't (although there are many who see
homosexual orientation as something in need of healing)^ Is
our sexuality a gift from God or not? Some strange c w j
is afoot to allow someone a gift and then not let^WBs
celebrate it. These are human lives which these producers of
statements, motions and bigotry are dealing with. Lesbians
and gay men aren't free in our heterosexist society: they
are legislated against, discriminated against, disowned,
abused, attacked. Christian lesbians and gay men often have
further fear heaped upon them, and recent CofE
pronouncements aren't going to help them to come out, and
to enjoy the freedom of knowing their sexuality is accepted
Richard Kirker, general secretary of the Lesbian and Gay
Christian Movement (LGCM) is right in naming an "insidious
sexual apartheid".
And, with deaconesses and the advent of women deacons, the
CofE is going to have to face up to lesbians in the ranks
of its hierarchy (and what about lesbian and gay
congregation members?). Lesbian Christians seem to be
largely ignored - a subtle form of oppression. And, of
course, the whole issue isn't limited to the CofE - it's of
vital importance to Churches and Christians everywhere.
Surely Christians have concerns to bring to human sexuality
other than a fixation on, largely male, mainly ger^XL,
homosexual expression. Where's respect,
communication, love, concern and pre cautions? Jot
particularly in some State-Christian institution of
heterosexual monogamous marriage, in which woman's
oppression is often compounded and legalised. Jot in a
Church where the issue of two men or two women loving one
another and expressing themselves, among many ways,
sexually (and not necessarily genitally at that), causes
more concern than the constant oppression, objectification
1938
“First they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out-
Because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for the communists
And I did not speak out-
Because I was not a communist.
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out-
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for me-
And there was no one left
To speak out for me.”
Pastor Niemoller
1988
SPEAK OUT NOW FOR LESBIANS AND GAYS
STOP CLAUSE 28
Clause 28 of the Local Government Bill
is an attack on everyone’s freedom
2
and violence done to women; more than the fear which two
people who love each other may live under.
All this prejudice will have effects - is having effects.
Gay priests, lesbian priests, and all homo-sexual Christians
live in fear of discovery or denunciation and rejection. The
Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement's office in St Botolph's,
Aldgate, is under threat. It' not homosexuals who need
healing of their sexuality (though alot have had many hurts
inflicted upon them) - it's our heterosexist society".
I have coihe that you may have life
and have it in its full
Let's educate ourselves - share ideas, experiences, talk with
lesbian and gay Christians and non-Christians, learn about
their lives and realise that same very real people are being
trampled on and kicked out by Churches and people who show
little love or toleration, and a great deal of ignorance and
prejudice.®
Lesley „,r4 nd Stephen
CHRISTIAN ANARCHY
- GIVE IT A GO
"A Pinch of Salt" enters Its third year with this bumper Issue,
and Christian Anarchy approaches its third millenium. A vision
of the Kingdom of God among us has inspired the lives of many,
throughout the centuries, in the pursuit of lives, communities
and a world based on freedom, peace and Justice. The joy and
insecurity of following Jesus has filled the hearts of all
6orts of people. A few sparks of hope have been kicked through
time, and their vitality can, at times, take hold of us: we
become that revolutionary fool for Christ, if only for a.
moment. Other times, we feel isolated, perhaps hopeless,
si jnded by injustice and the perversion of human needs and
th&^human spirit. The momentum of various oppressive systems
may seem to tower above us - militarism,
capitalism,"communism", patriarchy - and we may feel little
more than a grain of 6and, barely able to make a scratch in
the cogs of such phemomenal machinery.
Some Christians have, over the last two thousand years, tried
all manner of individual and collective expression in their
lives of discipleship to create and herald the upside down
order of the Gospel. Their marginalised histories, stories,
experiments and writings can be discovered, and give us
strength - the pacifist-communist early church, the early
Franciscans, Valdensians, Lollards, Anabaptists, Taborites,
Quakers, Diggers, Conscientious Objectors, Tolstoyans, and so
on. We can draw inspiration and strength from people and
activities going on around us today - the Plowshares activists,
Catholic Worker Movement, radical underground churches
struggling for peace and freedom in the eastern bloc, humble
grassroots communities in inner cities, civil rights protesters
in Guatemala, comralted individuals we may meet. But we must
not just marvel at these little histories, these failed but
inspiring movements, these heroic figures. The purpose of
inspiration is to inspire. There are no saints. We are all
saints - made from the same God-given stuff of humanity, and
the sparks of God that fly through history are just as capable
of setting alight you and me as they are Dorothy Day or
Francis of Assisi. It is a denial of the Spirit for Churches -
and Christian Anarchists - to put people on pedestals and to
say "How inspiring, but I could never...."
Radical Christian spiritual-political expression is dominated
by state-socialism, be it reformist or "revolutionary". Our
Marxist-inspired Christian sisters and brothers struggling for
Photo on back page: Peter Tatchell shouted "bigots" from the
public gallery as members of the General Synod stood to say
grace after backing January's statement by David Young, who
said he would refuse to ordain a priest he knew to be a
practicing homosexual.
"Lesbianism is a clear statement that a woman can and
wants to live without the male influence in her immediate
life. This threatens the very core of church and society,
which teaches that without man to lead and guide, woman
cannot survive.
"As one who struggles to hold together the tensions within
my sexuality and the church's unwritten prejudice towards
it, I am considering whether I can remain within the church
and be honest to my faith and to God"
a lesbian deacon
immiBmaiicmmfflmmiirammiii i iiiiiiBiiii E isiiiiiiiimiiiiniiimTBmii m mmiiimgimiaiPiiiiiJiiiiii BiinTiininnTtniiinniTnn
liberation in South America, Asia and Africa, are right in
saying that we need to draw tools and methods for analysis
and change from more recent political expressions. The
workings of multinational corporations aren't dealt with
sufficiently by Isaiah or James (though they have a good go).
Seeds of justice, peace and freedom (which are abundant in the
Bible) need nurturing, and we have to be humble and
adventurous enough to look to other traditions and insights -
be they feminism or cooperative economic ventures. But do we
need to chain ourselves to the power structures of state
socialism, and the hope and tactics of "gaining power"? Do we
have to carry on concocting arguments to justify hierarchies,
the sanctity of laws, the altruism of government, the incap¬
ability of ordinary people controlling their own ordinary lives
- be it in relation to churches or state?
The kernels of anarchism are all around for us to discover: the
upside down priorities of the gospels, the levelling of rich
and poor, the hope of "powerlessness", the strength of small-
scale collective action, the lives and writings of anarchists,
the obvious violence which state systems necessitate; the
simple observation that power structures are precisely that -
protectors of power, even if it is the altruistic power of the
middle classes. Christians know the worth of each individual,
the potential of communion, of community, the freedom of the
spirit. Anarchists know that factories don't need a class of
bosses, that workers can own and control production,
distribution, land, that communities can plan and provide
truely appropriate housing, that anarchists can run the bus
service.
Anarchy in churches. Anarchy in homes. Anarchy in the
workplace. Anarchy at military bases. Anarchy in the City of
London. Anarchy in supermarkets. Anarchy in the Yorkshire
Dales. Each of us, responsible, made in the image of God,
joining together, being those Christian anarchists we always
wanted to be. Ho more heros. Be perfect. Or, at least, give it a
go*
Christian anarchists of the world unite ^
We have nothing to lose but out reputation ® ^5
Stephen
— Q- •
r c u u
o . ®
(U C 2
x a a,
Brian Willson
Counting the Cost
“Just a tragic accident,” Captain Gary
Ford of the Contra Costa County sheriff s
office in California called it. A spokes¬
man for the military agreed. It was an
“accident”
The forty-seven-year-old veteran, S.
Brian Willson had joined a handful of
others in kneeling on the tracks on which
a munitions train was to travel through
the Naval Weapons Station in Concord,
California, on its way to Port Chicago on
San Francisco Bay. Final destination —
El Salvador. Since June, a coalition of
groups had been demonstrating at the
base. With the advent of each new muni¬
tions train, the same events would play
themselves out: Demonstrators would
inform officials at the base and the local
law enforcers that they would be block¬
ing the train’s path in protest of the
United States’ warmaking in Central
America. At the same spot each time
they would take their place on the tracks
near where they crossed a highway and a
stretch of public land. The train would
then appear, traveling about five miles
an hour, and stop in front of the as¬
sembled group. Local police would arrest
the participants and take them away.
On September 1, as always, notices
were given, and Brian Willson held a
press conference. The police good-
naturedly pleaded that this time they
stop the train before it got to the high¬
way, so that they would not have so
many angry motorists on their hands.
A whistle was heard, and the train
emerged, headed toward the highway
crossing. It seemed to pick up speed, ac¬
cording to some there, as it moved
toward the protesters. People on either
side of the tracks began calling to the
train to stop, that people were still in the
way. There were two men riding shotgun
in front of the train, as always, to check
for obstacles in its path. One just shook
his head as the engine advanced.
As it was almost upon them, the pro¬
testers began to jump out of the way,
and the last was Brian Willson, who had
moved into a semicrouch and was push¬
ing himself out of the way when the train
struck him. He was pulled under, his
right leg severed below the knee, and his
other leg so badly mutilated that it was
later amputated, and several head injur¬
ies sustained. The train continued over
him, not coming to a full stop until it was
fully past the highway, and several hun¬
dred feet into the base.
Accidents of Death
We are expected to understand this as
an “accident,” not so strange, in a way,
since death often is spoken of now as an
accident. Ben Linder, the young man
from the United States who was killed by
the Contras last April, while working on
an electrical project near El Cua, Nicara¬
gua, wag said to be in the wrong place at
the wrong time. Surely so many civilians
killed in the Nicaraguan countryside by
the Contras, are, by and large, not plan¬
ned assassinations, as is true for so many
who die in the bombings we finance and
oversee in El Salvador. “Accidental” too,
are the millions of deaths that would
result from a “justifiable” use of nuclear
weapons against military targets. They
are called, neatly, “collateral damage.”
We do not intend to kill the people them¬
selves. They happen to be killed during
our other - intentional - activities, which
are deemed honorable and necessary.
This is a problem of language, one
might say, but it is hardly just words at
stake. In any other situation, a slow mov¬
ing train would have stopped before
reaching people in its way. But it didn’t.
And, in the strange logic of things, be¬
cause it was part of such a conscious de¬
cision, the injury sustained, very predict¬
ably, was termed an accident. “It really
was not because they wanted to kill any¬
one that they didn’t stop, it was be¬
cause. . . ” Something is there to shield
the motives at work, and prevent their
association with the consequences.
On board the train was ammunition for
helicopter machine guns, white-phos¬
phorous rockets, and heavy demolition
bombs all destined for El Salvador. But
those who loaded it, drove it, unloaded
its cargo in El Salvador, packed it in on
aircraft, flew to targets and there releas¬
ed the contents-all of them are not said
to be simply trying to kill others, they
are.. . .
Brian Willson is now back home, recov¬
ering well. At a press conference while he
was still hospitalized, he stated:
Every time those munitions trains
go past us, some people are going to
be killed or maimed. When we come
to feel sincerely that the lives of
those people are worth no less than
our own lives, we become fully liber¬
ated ... Our own government can
only continue its wars with the
cooperation of our people, and that
cooperation is with our taxes and
our bodies. Our actions and our ex¬
pressions are what are needed—not
our whispers and our quiet dinner
conversation.
Hard words. The words of Jesus on dis-
cipleship come to mind, “For which of
you, desiring to build a tower, does not
first sit down and count the cost,
whether he has enough to complete it?”
(Luke 14:18) How long people in Central
America and elsewhere have been count¬
ing the cost of so many “justifiable” ac¬
tions on our part, and now we begin
counting this same cost ourselves. “Who¬
ever would save his life will lose it, and
whoever loses his life for My sake will
find it.” (Matthew 16:25). Hard words.
Are we ready to give up our lives? Are we
willing to enter into the sacrifice of
Christ?
The local district attorney concluded
on September 20 that in the matter in¬
volving Brian Willson there was no basis
for criminal charges. Other investiga¬
tions are pending, fl
TIM LAMBERT .
The above article comes from the Dec¬
ember issue of the Catholic Worker.
Brian is a member of Veterans Fast
For Life. Letters may be sent to him:
c/o Elizabeth Hallett
1827 Haight St., Box#3
San Francisco, CA 94117 USA
"What shall separate us from the love
of Christ? Shall tribulation, or dis¬
tress, or persecution, or famine, or
nakedness, or peril, or sword....No..
But in all things we overwhelmingly
conquer through him who loved us."
Romans 8.35
No U.S.
Intervention in
Dineh (Navajo)
and Hopi Lands
Stop P.L. 93-531
Ministry of Defence
cjtipfxrl’ DiffilitiegisfancC'
lntaraatiofial .Big- [DotmkiinX^ek Fifie'l 2"^
3S6&
invasion, a threat that streaks
across their skies in the form of
The government of the United
States, while doing the bidding
of the energy barons, plans the jets and helicopters,
forced removal of thousands of
Dineh (Navajo) People from their Traditional
traditional home to new lands caretakers
which are radioactive because of
spills from the uranium mines.
The Dineh land is wanted for its
coal, oil, natural gas and
uranium. The U.S. government
fabricated a so-called ''dispute"
between the Dineh and their
neighbours,^ the Hopis, to
manoeuver f their ancestral protest
homelands away from them.
Peoples are the
of Mother Earth. If
they are to survive, they need
our help and support. The San
Diego BIG MOUNTAIN SUPPORT GROUP Resistance,
has initiated the organizing of 2. Help
the INTERNATIONAL BIG MOUNTAIN petitions, vigils, demonstrations
WEEK, APRIL 9th-16th. " in your area.
3. Reprint this information for
The purpose of the international organizations in your area.
protest
There is no dispute. The U.S.
Government and Mormon Church
created the "dispute" and control
is to place the Dineh 4-. Send us donations
Resistance before the eyes of the costs of organizing,
world with the demand that the 5.
United States
international human
treaties and resolutions
to cover
the Tribal Council, even though demanding that the United States
Hopi People and the end its systematic threat of
aditional Hopi Elders side with forced removal and all human
the Dineh. Traditional Hopi and rights abuses against the Dineh
Translate information into
follow other languages.
rights 6. Send us copies of all fliers,
We are articles or posters dealing with
International Big Mountain Week.
Write letters
to the U.S.
7. Get Vol. 1 & 2 if BIG MOUNTAIN
INFORMATION PACKETS ($5 each plus
postage) - all cheques payable to
this made it easy for the energy of human rights to Indian People B.M.S.G.
barons to get P.L. 93-531 passed by the government of the United
in the U.S. Congress mandating States of America. The policies government and embassy,
forced removal of the Dineh of genocide are still being
People. played out as Indian land is
stolen. Indian culture, religion,
Just north of Big Mountain is an and tradition is being willfully L. Floyd, Arthur J. Miller
area called the Black Mesa. destroyed.
Dineh do not believe in People,
participation in U.S. sponsored
elections and government. In 1972 There has been a historic denial
Project Coordinators: Christina
There, huge strip mining
equipment digs long trenches 150 The Dineh Resistance i
feet deep. Coal is taken from the of
INTERNATIONAL
RESOLUTION
OF
solidarity for the
trenches and the land is filled Government can, by law (P.L. 93-
in and "reclaimed". Not one’ foot 531), proceed at any time with
of "reclaimed" land has ever come their planned military
back. It is all dead land. These intervention. Help us send a
monster machines are heading in message, throughout the world,
the direction of Big Mountain. that the U.S. Government can no
longer mistreat the original
The Dineh have been forced to people of America or violate
in need SOL IPAR ITY
U. S
WITH
THE
DINEH
reduce 90% of their livestock every
^^hich is the main means of their resolution and
RESISTANCE
Whereas the Government of the
United States of America
continues its threat to force
thousands of Dineh from their
homelands, and continues to
violate the religious and human
rights of the Dineh people. We
the undersigned call for
international solidarity for the
international treaty
human rights Dineh Resistance at Big Mountain
If-survival). All construction agreement that it has signed with and endorse the International Big
nas been banned, water wells have regards to Indians,
been sabotaged, and the Dineh are
harassed and arrested by
government agents. They are under
Mountain Week, April 9th - 16th,
1938 .
Please help if you can.
1. Endorse the Resolution
constant threat of military Solidarity
with
the
of Name and
Dineh
full address of Group
<*TO MOVE AWAY MEANS TO DISAPPEAR
AND NEVER BE SEEN AGAIN."
—Paulme Whicesmjer
Try to get your church, anarchist
group, student group or whatever
to fill in the above endorsement.
Rather than fill i n an
endorsement on behalf of
Christians Anarchists (which is
impossible and unanarchic), send
in your name to "Pinch" if you
want to be included on an
endorsement from "some Christian
anarchists" - by 25th March at
the latest. Ta.
international Big fflountain^v^ek
jRfi. Sox 2576 San Qieqo^Ca. 92U2, U.S. A
P.S. Anyone interested in a vigil
outside the U.S. Embassy sometime
during the week, get in touch and
we'll arrange and publicise.®
5
“POES BEIIsIG A CHRISTIAN AHI>
A SOLDIEK Fir TOGETHERl < *
The following article appeared in Peace News No. 2302 of last year. It's a shortened version of an interview of Mark
Lane which Viv Kendon recorded when in Mutlangen, West Germany. Mark, an ex-soldier, worked in the US Army for 11 years
before being discharged as a conscientious objector (CO) early last year.
I joined the army in February 1976. In January 1978 I was
transferred to Schwabish Ground, West Germany, and
worked with Pershing la missiles until May 1982. Then I spent
a year in the US as an instructor for Pershing la, and in July
1983 I was sent back to Germany, to Heilbronn where I
worked on the change-over from Pershing la to Pershing 'll.
What was it like working with Pershing?
The training is supposed to make you automatic, like a robot,
so you could count a missile to fire it even in your sleep. At
least one a month, NATO and the US Army have an alert; the
soldiers aren't supposed to know if it's real or not. Once we
had a training countdown at about 3am, and were back in bed
again by about 4.30. In the morning someone said to me
"Hey, that was a pretty good count you guys did last night,"
and I realised I couldn't remember anything about it, not even
getting out of bed.
And Libya? When the US bombed Libya everythinq
on manoeuvres. It really looked to us like the US
paring for war to break out.
went out
was pre-
They wfsren'i going out to fight, they were going out to hide.
The US was really scared of a terrorist attack, so thev hid
everything. - ~ - y u
The US does a lot of things overseas without telling NATO, or
their "host countries"; the US is part of NATO but doesn't
trust NATO.
If the stuff the US has already is scary enough, like backpack
nuclear bombs more powerful than Hiroshima, what they are
planning is worse. Martin Marietta has already submitted
plans for a Pershing III which will look just like a civilian truck
driving along the road, the driver will be in civilian clothes,
and the launch sites will look like civilian factories. The US
military is already buying up old factories in Germany using a
front company.
So what made you want to get out?
It was a religious experience in the spring of 1984, which both
me and my wife had together. For 19 months I sat there
fighting it, fighting myself, fighting God, fighting the world,
fighting everyone. How does being a Christian and being a
soldier fit together? I did lots of Bible study and lots of talking
with my wife. Finally I decided I would have to quit one, and
being a Christian was more important in my life.
In December 1985 I resisted for the first time, I refused to pull
guard duty on Pershing 11 at Heilbronn. In January 1985 I
applied for a discharge as a CO. As soon as I made the
application they kept me away from anything sensitive. In
February 1987 I refused to wear the uniform. It was the only
symbol that told the world that I was a soldier, and because I
was not one to myself, I did not want the world to think, of me
as one. Finally, in March 1987, I was released with an
honourable discharge.
The decision to quit wearing the uniform was the hardest. I
talked to my wife all evening, then I talked to Bill Boston of
the Military Counseling Project in Mutlangen for an hour on
the telephone, then a Vietnam veteran, then some other
people, I talked on the phone till 3 or 4am. I got up the next
morning, put on the uniform and thought, "no, it's too much
of a risk", and sat down to breakfast. 1 spent the next hour
dithering, then took it off, wrote a brief statement, and called
up Bill to tell him. I felt good about it all the way to work. The
First Sergeant said "I don't know what to do" and he phoned
the lawyers. Eventually, I was passed on to the commander
who ordered me to put the uniform on. The military lawyers
urged me to accept a non-judicial punishment, and the
civilian lawyers said 1 had no chance of winning if I took it to
Mark Lane
court to try to win the right for others to do the same. Then
they asked if I would accept a bar to re-enlistment and
request a discharge on that basis, I agreed so long as I did not
have to put the uniform back on. So they gave me a non¬
judicial punishment of a $600 fine and the loss of one rank.
My commander gave me a letter giving me permission not to
wear the uniform and a week later I was out, a civilian.
What was the reaction of family and friends?
My family was pleased, the kids knew I hated being a soldier
and wearing the uniform, and it would mean I had more time
to spend with them. Most families in the army complain they
never see their fathers.
All my friends turned their backs on me. Younger soldiers
respected me but kept their distance because it might cause
problems for them. The wives of other soldiers turned their "
backs on my wife and their kids wouldn't play with our kids.
My Captain, who was a close friend, wrote in the statement
he had to make on my CO application that he didn't feel I was
sincere, just trying to find an easy way out of the army. Then
he wouldn't talk to me again until two weeks before I got out,
when he was being transferred. Then he apologised for what
he had written, said he had felt gulity about it, but he had held
it in for a whole year.
When did you get in touch with the peace movement?
There were regular blockades at Heilbronn: when I applied
for my discharge I said to my wife, "the day I get out I'm
going to be on the other side of that gate blockading". But my
first contact with the peace movement wasn't until January
1987.
Until then I kept away from contact with the peace movement
to try to keep out of more trouble. It is illegal for a US soldier
to demonstrate in a foreign country. January 11, 1987 was
the anniversary of the accident at Walheide and my wife went
to the vigil there. She talked to a woman who introduced her
to another woman and through her I met Bill Boston. I had
expected the reaction to be "well, what can you tell us?"
Instead it was "How can we help you?".
What are you doing now?
Once I had decided to leave I started looking round for what
God wanted me to do. I went through all the possibilities of
religious work but none of them quite fitted. Now I'm a peace
worker and a counsellor for soldiers who face problems with
the military or who want out. I'm working with Bill Boston
and a few others. We have established a Military Counselling
6
Network n ere in Germany and work along with the Central
Committee for Conscientious Objectors in the US. I would
encourage the sam^ to be set up in other countries where
there are US soldiers.
« AT THE SEUIU
What's important to you now?
Religion, and what it means to world peace. My beliefs get
strc^ce' o. me cay. To clear my conscience I find I have to
clea' o-t me es :ne military has taught me. It is impossible
for me to stand by and keep letting the military take over our
lives a~z me world. Because of this I have done a lot of
lectu res, interviews and speeches since the day I got out. I am
also working with a lot of groups like the Presshutte in
Muttargen or the Freidensforschung in Stranberg (a peace
reseamn institute near Munich). They are also helping to
make sure I don't get into trouble by saying too much that is
sensitive or classified for the military.
What is the most threatening aspect of the military now for
you?
The money behind it all. The military-industrial complex is so
big. t Keeps developing and developing and then selling the
weapons to the military, even when the military doesn't need
the weapons.
Since Vietnam, there's been the concept that human soldiers
aren't that dependable, so they are starting to design robots
There is a little robot car that takes the place of a scout—al
remote control radar and computer. There are even personal
jet cars so that soldiers don't have to march any more. But
they also don't care about human soldiers, if they get killed in
operations, tf a base is in danger of being captured they will
destroy it, never mind if all the soldiers are out the way or
On March of last year Huntingdon Magistrates sent¬
enced Rev. Michael Scott, Mik the Vic, to 30 days
in prison for the non-payment of £225 fines, incur
red after celebrating Christmas on USAF Alconbury
runway and painting "Hands Off Nicaragua" on the
same runway on Ascension Day. In a letter printed
in "Koinonia"* the newsletter of Clergy Against
Nuclear Arms Mik wrote the following:
"After 24 hours in Bedford I was moved to Ranby,
given a beautiful room and was helped by a Jamaican,
who mopped the corridors while I sang hymns so
loudly they threatened to lock me up.* My fellow
criminals were extremely friendly and the author¬
ities charming. The Chaplain invited me to the
altar in my prison clothes to say the Eucharistic
Testament, because everything in the Gospels was
happening to me.
I commended a fellow inmate for belonging to the
Animal Liberation Front, as it was founded by Jesus
Christ, when he released the pigeons and livestock
from cages, reared for obsolete sacrifices for a
religion maintained by corrupt monetarists. The
officers were worried. If I was successful I might
do them out of a job. "Have no fear", I reassured
them, "if I succeed in converting people to my
version of Christianity, you'll never be out of a
job, as your prisons will be bursting at the
HIM
s earn s. •
not
My last time on duty at Walheide, the wrong code was sent to
headquarters. The code that was sent put the entire base
under duress, so bombers were sent in to destroy the base
that was supposedly under threat. We were desperately
trying to send the right code back to headquarters so they
would not destroy the site and us. Meanwhile the pilots of the
,*ju8ts were fly ng over us and radioing back I don t see any
oblems, do you still want us to go ahead?" ■
Contacts for military counselling in West Germany: Bill Boston, Military
Counseling Project Mutiangen, Forststr 3, D-7075 Mutlangen; Mark Lane,
Military aTd Draft Counseling, Rob Koch-str 3, D-6927 Bad Rappenau;
U~ :ed States : Central Committee for Conscientious Objectors, 2208 South
Street Philadelphia PA 19146: Citizen Soldier, 175 Fifth Avenue, Room 808,
New York NY 10010 (publishers of On Guard, a newspaper for Do soldiers),
Brits r War Resisters International, 55 Dawes Street, London SE17 1EL; tel
01-7037189; At Ease _ _
Hello Stephen
ONE OF THREE LETTERS
*CANA, 38 Main Road, Norton, Evesham, Worcs. WR11
Peaceful protest: Members of Christian CND marking Holy Innocents Day
by picketing a Ministry of Defence office at Bath.
...I hope everything is going alright in Birmingham
- "A Finch of Salt" last issue was very interesting
Having finally got a copy of Eller's "Christian
Anarchy" I can't help agreeing wholeheartedly with
your article. Eller seems to have decided that
Anarchism means whatever Eller decides and Christ¬
ianity even more so. Whatever it is that he
believes to be the vision of the Kingdom (and I'd
defy anyone to get behind all of his ridiculous
theological red-herrings and hero worship to find
out) it doesn't seen to be one of any action or
change atall. The world doesn't get turned upside
down with Eller's Christian Anarchism; it is left
exac tly as it is with one man feeling slightly
more at hoee in it now he's found a niche for him¬
Oh dear I'm being a bit judgemental, but mind you,
I found the book enormously irritating. After all
it's not so much that he's utterly misrepresented
the Christian Anarchist tradition - it's not labels
that mean anything to us - but he's just judged the
whole purpose of our lives - to be partakers in the
radical kingdom of God - when he could have got so
near to it if he'd thought about the implications «.
of the title a bit more.
Ah!
Anyway, thanks for keeping it all going. APoS
means quite a bit to me now as I'm sure it does to
a lot of others.
Your friend,
♦ *
Justin Meggitt.
self •
7
solidarity With plowshares prisoners
"IS IT POSSIBLE TO BE
VIOLENT TO A NUCLEAR
WARHEAD? I JUST LIKE
TO TAP AT THEM. ”
On September 9th, 1980, the "Plowshares Eight" entered
a General Electric plant in King of Prussia, Pennsyl¬
vania where the nose cones for the Mark 12A nuclear war¬
heads were manufactured. With hammers and blood they
enacted the Biblical prophecies of Isaiah(2:4) and
Micah(4:3) to "beat swords into ploughshares" by
hammering on two of the nose cones and pouring blood on
documents. They were subsequently arrested, tried, con¬
victed and sentenced.
Recognizing the imminent peril nuclear weapons pose for
all life, there have been other communities and individ¬
uals since the Plowshares Eight action who, after a
process of spiritual preparation and reflection have
symbolically yet concretely disarmed components of U.S.
first-strike strategy, and, more recently, U.S. Central
American interventionary equipment. There have been
twenty five such actions, so far, two of which took
place in Germany. None so far have taken place in
Britain. Sentences have been as high as eighteen years.
"So when we break the law legalizing the end of the
world - we are saving lives. When we resist Trident II
or Reagan's Contra war-we are saving lives. And
when we enact Isaiah 2 and Plowshares, linking First
Strike and interventionary war to Reagangate, we are
saving lives. And when we survive in the empire's
jails, we are indeed saving lives. Those in jail for
nonviolent resistance, know the bottom line, live the
bottom line.
....We need the imagination that flows from faith.. .We
are insisting on social and political morality beyond
the capacities of politicians.
....Finally - we ought to resist when we discover any
tendency to think that God is like us. We are command¬
ed to be like God."
(Philip Berrigan, quoted in Plowshares News¬
letter)
The following letter is one from Jerry Ebner, printed
in "AT THE DOOR", Newsletter of the St Francis Catholic
Worker in Chicago. We reported Jerry's and Joe's and
Helen's disarmament action in the last "Pinch of Salt".
Joe and Jerry have since been and sentenced, and would
welcome letters and cards of support.
I will always say the same.
( Maybe not always with the teeth showing in my smile.)
... but still a resounding yes. The simple reason is
that I was very sure about the action on the day we did
it. It was the most joyfilled day of my life. Like a
dream come true...that it really came to pass...even as
planned.
I still have a slight sense of sadness..only because
I know our action is not the only answer or the last
answer. Our action was very simple, modest in taste
and symbolic. More Disarmament work needs to continue.
I am only one person. I can do so much, but only so
much, the rest of ot os often beyond us, but also
within us while acting in conspiracy with the Holy
Spirit.
As I see it, for myself, I was acting in concert with
the tradition of the Catholic Worker Movement in which
Dorothy and Peter Maurin spoke of: "We move away from a
self centred individualism toward the good of the other
This is to be dome by taking responsibility for
changing conditions rather than looking towards the
state or ether institutions to provide impersonal
charity".
The usual practice of that has been for Catholic
Workers to takeresponsibility to be family to the
houses of houses and offer them a home and hospitality
rather than asking the government to open houses of
hospitality.
In regards to militarism and disarmament of nuclear ^
weapons - who is going to disarm these weapons of ours
while the government builds five more each day and
assemble them in Amarillo, TX?
Who is going to lead others to the real hope that
disarmament is possible? Or are we to leave the work
of justice to the stae or other institutions to provide
impersonal charity. (By and large we've done this while
the government only talks aims control while building
more.)
Our action (Joe, Helen, and I) is only symbolic ..
a symbol speaks to a larger reality. Much more than
what we did needs to be done.
"The harvest is rich, but the workers are few; there¬
fore asj the harvest master to send workers to the har¬
vest. Be on your way, and remember I am sending you as
lambs into the midst of wolves." (Luke 10:2-3)
3'erry Ebner
QOOOOOOOOOOOOOOQOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCGOOOOCXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX»
Jerry is interested in studying more about Christian
socialism and Christian anarchism, and loves personal
letters: write....Jerry Ebner 04467-045
F.C.I. Box 1000
Sandstone, MN 55072, USA ^
Joe writes "I am still trying to figure why Jerry and I
got 30 & 40 months and 4 years probation when we did
$12,920 damage and my wife got 6 years and 5 years
probation when her share of the damage was $424.48
Jean was imprisoned for a previous Plowshares action:
write.Joe Gump 04468-045 Jean Gump 03789-045
Oxford F.P.C. Alderson Women's Prison
Oxford, Wisconsin, USA Box A, Alderson,
WV 24910
Dear Friends,
I was asked to share any reflections about the 23rd
Plowshares action that I and two others participated
in, on August 5, 1987.
At first my response was, "Oh please, don't ask me
to do that, I'm not a very good writer, and I certainly
can talk too much, as the best of my friends will tell
you" (Don't all jump and testify to the truth at the
same time.) ^
The County jail, the Lafayette County jail where I am
now after the third and fourth transfers by the U.S.
marshalls, is hot a good place to reflect upon much of
anything- except the noise and the crazy reasons why
other prisoners are here. However, I will be brief.
One needs all the truth one can keep, even at a distance
Many prisoners all ask Joe and I a similar question
in various ways. " Is it worth it?" realizing the
years of prison time. Without much responce time I say
"Yes!" with excitement and a smile on my face. I think
8
An up-to-date list of prisoners' addresses and support
groups is available from "Pinch of Salt", including a
description of all the actions. It's a sixteen page
booklet - send 20 pence in stamps and a SAE. We've
also got. some "Swords Into Ploughshares" and "Solidarity
With Plowshares Prisoners" badges (25p) and some
posters of Larry Cloud Morgan hammering a missile silo
(black and red A3, 20p). Any donations to cover costs
of publicity leaflets is welcome. Hoping to bring out a
good leaflet in time for the Aldermaston demo. Cheques
payable to "A Pinch of Salt".
There's a European gathering for Christian peace makers
in June, where Plowshares issues will be discussed. Get
in touch via "Pinch" if you're interested.
Also, I'm definitely hoping to arrange a gathering for
British people interested in Ploughshares actions and
themes, so write if you want to be put on the publicity
mailing list. Oh yes, I've got copies of the latest
"Ploughshares Newsletter" for 40p - well worth the
read. • spears Into Pruning Hooks &c.
(xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Stephen oooooooooocoooooo
CAPITALISM- NOT SO MOCK UNCK^lSTIAH AS ANTKHfllSTMN
In 1937 R.H.Tawney wrote a memorandum for a church
conference describing capitalism in terms which
seem to apply today :
"Capitalism today . is not so much un-Christian
as anti-Christian .... It has indeed, like it’s
totalitarian rival miscalled Communism, some of
the characteristics of a counter religion. Its
emphasis on the supreme importance of material
riches ; the intensity of its appeal to the
acquisitive appetites of material riches; and the
skill with which it plays on them; its worship
of economic power its subordination of human be¬
ings to the exigencies , or supposed exigencies, of
an economic system, as interpreted by other human
beings who have a pecuniary interest in interpret¬
ing them to their own advantage; it s erection of
divisions within the hauman family based on differ¬
ences, notimerely of personal quality and social
function, but of income and of economic circumst¬
ances- these qualities are closely related to the
end which capitalist societies hold to be ail-imp¬
ortant. In such societies as the practice of the
above clearly shows, they are commonly regarded not
s vices but as virtues. To the Christian they are
— ices more ruinous to the soul than most of the
conventional forms of immorality."
Yes, yes ... written in 1937 that all applies in
1987- increasingly. The monster is not dying: it
continues to grow. It s stench is poisoning the
world, as George Lansbury used to say. We see that
more and more that capitailism- ruthless competit¬
ion - is destroying it s own base of operations-
the planet. It is, however both useless and impos¬
sible to try to kill the monster. We have to slow
it down, stop it in it s tracks and put the animal
into reverse. If humanity goes backwards into dis¬
aster as the capitalist system of accumulation goes
forward, the reverse will be true. As the system
wanes and dwindles, humanity will grow and flower.
It cannot be done by violence which only brings
something worse - such as the system miscalled
Communism (Tawney's phrase). Therefore it cannot be
done by state laws in the beginning or at all so
long as the state consists of a mass of warring
individuals dividing ourselves into classes and
factions, tribes and nations, each seeking to
^bjugate their neighbour or competitor in busi-
ness
A
’You have sold the righteous for silver and the
needy for a pair of shoes."Amos 2:6
simply because the community does not yet exist.
Legislation for this purpose can only do one of two
things: either create a chaos of unenforceable laws
....or a new bureaucratic monster.
"Community" can only be created by the conquest
of violence by love and patience, as the Digger
leader Gerrard Winstanley affirmed more than 300
years ago: that is by "families of love".' Begin¬
ning in tiny groups, these families ever extending,
meeting, coalescing - engulfing the monsters with
faith, hope and charity, with love and laughter.
Satan can’t stand laughter: good humoured laughter.
Satanic laughter is, of course, satanic: pitiable.■
Dick Connell
"The "Family of Love" conception (16th Century) is
explained by Christopher Hill, "The World Turned
Upside Down".
VIRAJ MENDIS WILL STAY
state without violence would not be a state. One
mistake consists in talking about "The Community"
when referring to our present "society" of violent,
warring groups and individuals: the word "community"
should mean "being one together" just as the word
invest" should mean putting clothes on people, at
present half naked, instead of using their labour
to overfill ones own wardrobe. In particular the
excellent^notion that land should belong to "The
Community" cannot be put into effect by legislation,
DEFEND THE SANCTUARY I
AMD SET THE PRISONERS FREE*.
The other week I appeared before Birmingham Mag¬
istrates Court for three unpaid fines related to
anti-nuclear protests over the last one and a half
years. Following through my assertion that what I
had done was proper, and maintaining a spirit of
unrepentance, I was prepared for a prison sentence -
nervous, but resigned. It was to be my first time in
prison in this country (the previous sentence was in
Denmark for painting on a runway, but the whole epi¬
sode was surreal and didn’t affect me much). I came
out of prison a week later, tired, not having eaten,
depressed and disempowered by the most sustained
atmosphere of violence I’ve ever experienced. In
relation to the sentences and suffering people
undergo the world around, my experience was mere
scratches, and slightly embarassing - being in for
a week (in a cell 13 feet by 6 feet, meant for one)
with someone in for ten years and someone in for
life. But, if telling my experience can lift a few
illusions, and especially make some Christians think
about the nature of our "law and order" system and
their relationship to it, then they’ll be words well
sp^nt.
Court was simple, brief, and I felt strong and
clear. I was given time to speak, and wasn’t
hassled by the clerk, who I 'd met in less relaxed
procedings in previous court cases. I told the
magistrates the activities behind my fines, why I
wouldn’t pay, and why I thought they had no right
to make enforceable judgements, finishing with a
good rule of thumb: "let the person without sin
cast therfirst stone". Three friends were in court
to support me. One of the two magistrates was a
vicar. The sentence was soon announced: "Two weeks..
...two weeks....one week....to be served concurrent¬
ly" (ie two weeks in all, with half off for "good
behaviour", making one week - in Tuesday, out
Monday morning). The officer who took me away could¬
n’t find a way down to the cells, so we wandered
around the courts a bit - bumped into Roger, Mark
and Jay again, said goodbye - and finally descended.
Again, in the custody of the court police, I was
asked some personal details, including my date of
birth, which I again refused. They said they were
a fairly tolerant lot, but there were others who
weren't so, and that I was just banging my head
against a brick wall and would just end up bloody
and bruised. Quite threatening words just before
going into prison. «X was in a cell for an hour, with
time to sing and think of, especially, political
prisoners around the world. I watched and listened
to the banter of the prison officers - through.* * .
my cell-door hatch I could just see hands on hips,
chains on keys, and wrestling. There were also
shouts of "Greenham Common", periodic stares into
my cell, and an awful racist joke, which drew merely
laughter. There were black people in the cells, all
within hearing range, absorbing further racism from
agents of a system who make no pretence of equality.
The symbol and power of keys was to be a recurring
image.
10
I was then led to a prison van, and locked in a
cramped cubicle a bit like a compressed confession
box, and driven to prison - I followed the route
through some scratches in the blackened glass.
Arriving at Her Majesty's Prison Winson Green, we -
about ten of us - were taken to the reception block
- a brand new habitat-red-woodwork building. I
thought of the painted lorries which transported
Jews to their deaths. A bit too dramatic a parallel,
but unnerving enough. The public end of the legal
system is grand enough, and hides a transition into
a constantly humiliating process. One prisoner
looked terrified - I talked with him, and told him
what I knew of the daily routine. I ./was later to
see him gazing nervously out of a window in the
hospital wing as I walked around the exercise yard.
We nodded. I expect he has little if any outside
support.
I was the last "con" (short for convict) to be
processed; led into a room of six prison officers,
one behind a computer, one by some paper, another to
my right, one in front of me, and two to my left.
Name. Address. Date of Birth. "I'd rather not give
that." Three officers shouted "You've got to give
it.’" I was struck with fear and a slight touch of
amusement at their anger and incredulity - because
I didn't really have to give them any information.
But such thoughts were abruptly curtailed as the
officer in front of me hit me in the stomach. I bent
over, winded. He pulled me up by my hair. I could
only whisper "That hurt." Fear and an awful recog¬
nition of powerlessness whirled around me and knot¬
ted and sickened my aching stomach. I half expected
more punches to follow, "What's your date of birth?"
I explained why I didn't give it - that I didn't
want to support an impersonal system based on
violence, but I spoke with little confidence.
Fortunately, the officer behind the computer found
the date in some obscure records - I conceded it
was correct. I wasn't up to prolonged confrontation.
The fear of further blows subsided. I had been
initiated. I was in my place. The officer in front
of me had done his job. Religion? "Non-church
Christian." "Oh, fucking hell..Church of England."
Off I went to the next stage in my initiation rite
- weighing, shower, clothes.
The prisoners giving me clothes joked around and I
ended up with trousers half way up my legs - which
they eventually changed after I convinced them that,
no, I wasn't that short-sighted. One rule of prison
life: you have to find out everything yourself. Be
that prison rules, routine, library hours or what*v
ever. The myth of being furnished with a copy of
prison rules upon request is a standing joke. I
managed to work out I could get a jumper and
jacket, which I did. The shirts are dead smart.
Apparently, some prisons get broken into just to
nick the shirts to sell. Entrepreneurial spirit
pervades. Everyone in a soft blue denim - though
remand prisoners wear a different colour, or their
own clothes.
Personal expression is limited. Monotony is the
order of the day. The officers like to be called
"Boss'’. You walk up those stairs, down those stairs,
and keep off the sacred yellow tiles. Joking with
A week. iKi Win son CiftLdoi
other prisoners: each evening the guards chose a
specific tile, don't tell you which one, and if you
walk on it, you immediately get executed. Humour
turns upside down, makes more bearable, disrupts
the reality of four walls, enables escape. The
Governor is Darth Vader for a few seconds, the
prison officers forget to bring me breakfast in bed.
Press that button and ask for a sandwich, will you?
Where's the helicopter I ordered, i'll hire one when
I get out.
Then: the vegan catch twenty two. A play in many
acts. No, you can't have a vegan diet - you've got
to have a vegan card to be a vegan. I'd previously
decided that the one issue I would make a stand on
would be refusing to eat unless provided a proper
diet. You gotta make a stand somewhere. Alongside
not calling the officers "Boss" - strictly against
my religion. Well, I suppose I might have reconsid¬
ered, once beaten unconscious. Anyway, in the course
of my six days I was denied an application for a
vegan diet, threatened with a single cell, offered
cabbage and porridge, and saw the Principal Officer
three times. On the first meeting he said he didn't
care less if I didn't eat; the second he said it'd
be the padded cell if I didn't eat; the third, on
deprocessing. he did his official bi*t of asking me
I had any complaints, and then refused to write
uiem and told me to go away. So, it's impossible to
be a vegan without a vegan card. We won't give you
a proper diet, and you'll be punished if you don't
eat it. And, you're mad. And, no you can't use any
of the official complaints procedures. By about day
three I felt confident that the threats were bluffs,
and about day four some officers decided they defi¬
nitely couldn't care less, as I would be out in a
couple of days.
Still, the ill-ease of my fasting merged with dis-
empowerment, and I was never too sure if I felt low
because of hunger or hopelessness.
The first night is spent in one wing, and then you’
are moved to more permament accomodation. The
routine of prison life I'd been briefed clearly
about before I went in, and it worked out much less
pressured than my nervous mind had imagined. Sixish,
lights on. About twenty minutes' lie-in till door
bolt slid back. Slop out, go to the loo, get water
for washing. Locked in. Fifteen minutes later, go
downstairs for breakfast. Locked in for breakfast.
p out. Weather permitting, about 45 minutes of
txercise in the morning (it snowed, so I only got
out twice in six days - consequently spending about
23% hours a day in my cell, if not more). Lunch
about half eleven. Slop out. Fourish, tea. Slop out.
Half sixish, final slop out. (All these times could
be way out, as I had no access to a time machine)
Then, a prison officer comes in, tucks you into bed,
reads you a bed time story. "Goodnight Boss". "Good¬
night." "Boss." "Yes." "I love you Boss." "Now, try
to get some sleep." (this conversation may well be
fictional) And the clock turns full circle.
There are plenty of survival mechanisms. Sleep. Most
of the morning. A good part of the afternoon. Go to
bed early. Chat and loiter at every opportunity -
but don't push your luck. Jest and joke. Read -
library books, tabloids, pornography. Make models
out of matches - you can buy kits at the canteen
(you get £1.50 a week). Listen to a radio, if you've
got one. Play chess. Take drugs - be it the alcohol
from floor polish, tobacco, cannabis, heroin. In
some prisons, homebrew, but in Winson Green slop
buckets are checked. Masturbate. Write a letter.
Appeal against your sentence. Wash your hair. Day
dream. Wait for a visit. Chat. Smoke.
The thinnest cigarettes. A restless smell of stale
smoke, sweat, urine, disinfectant, lingers every¬
where. Radio One was on fourteen hours a day in my
cell - numbed to insensitivity and incessant head¬
ache, Sickened by a mindless culture. I've never
slept so badly, so consistently.
Two "treats" of the week - film and chapel. The
former in the chapel. I was told it was to be a car
chase, but it turned out to be a sex-fantasy murder.
About the most perverse and violent theme imagin¬
able - in the chapel, projected above the altar,
several jundred men watching the systematic object¬
ification, harassment, rape and murder of women. I
felt like shouting, but lacked confidence, and asked
a prison officer to take me back to my cell. I sat
down and whirled with intensity as I took in the
awfulness of such a scene - the nearest I got to
feeling prayerful throughout my sentence. When my
cell-mate got back from the film, we talked about
sexism, objectification, sex, sexuality, child-
rearing, morality, anarchy, biker culture, violence,
nonviolence, prison experiences, peace actions, and
more. Our series of conversations were really fruit¬
ful, despite being polar opposites in our priorities.
Indeed, I got no hassle off any of the other prison¬
ers, which had been one of my fears (though friends
have related quite terrible stories. Every experi¬
ence is different). They thought of me as, if any¬
thing, a sort of oddity, a stubborn vegan, only in
for a week. "We've been talking. You'd never make
a bank robber." Oh well.
The prison officers: the temptation to call them
"screws"; to dehunanise them as they dehumanise you.
I thought I'd be able to remember the one who hit
me, but I saw several who reminded me of him. The
cap peak lowered, the moustache, the contempt, the
confident swagger, the swearing:"Hancock, get the
fuck over there." The keys. The whistling just
before opening any important door. "Of course we
don't believe you. You're a prisoner." One or two
try to distance themselves from the behaviour of
their colleagues by touches of friendliness,
leniency, concern. But they all know the score, they
all know what goes on.
continued overleaf
11
The punishment block: the sound of running feet as
someone is taken down. Single cell. Cardboard furn¬
iture. Fear. The high possibility of being beaten
up. The tokenism of the tribunal, or whatever it's
called. I met one prisoner, who*d taken a cup of tea
at the wrong time, providing an excuse for victim¬
isation. Taken to the punishment block, into a
single cell. Beaten up; both arms twisted behind
his back till breaking point, then punched and
kicked about his front. Then told to make his bed.
He still can't bend his arms far behind his back,
and a bone is sticking out slightly in his chest.
Two years ago, I was told, Barry Prosser was
jumped upon till his stomach split. He died, was
murdered. The verdict - accidental death - he
slipped up on a cup. The officers involved were
merely transferred to other prisons. The constant
fear. The violence and hate and.power.
But, I managed to hold onto, to salvage the sense
of the futility of violence for violence, hate for
hate, despite my temptations to lapse into sarcasm.
Love did seem quite hopeless - not so much impossible
as not allowed or impractical. But not as hopeless
or futile as violence. Still, inhumanity reigns.
Retribution, revenge, punishment is the purpose of
your sentence. The chaplains carry keys, and there¬
by betray the prisoners, and blow many chances of
credibility or trust. "To preach the Good News to
the poor, restore sight to the blind, and set the
prisoners free........?"
In the chapel service on Sunday the chaplain talked
of conversion and said that most people were happy
with their lives as they were, and didn't want to
see things changed. Hardly the most appropriate
ministry to a congregation of prisoners. He even
asked two of the congregation to stay behind after¬
wards - not for punishment, but for "spiritual
guidance". Still, the Mission Praise songs were
blurted out with cacophonic humour, and it was
better than being in a cell. Some stayed behind for
communion.
Getting letters on Saturday (all seven came on the
one day) brought instant transformation to me. It's
amazing how uplifting such tokens of support are. I
could imagine concern, support, prayers, but my
imagination was dampened. Getting the letters, I
couldn't suppress a broad smile - happiness and
slight embarassraent at the attention.
On Sunday afternoon I wrote my final letter, decid¬
ing to write to Martin Forran (see article below) as
an act of solidarity. All letters incoming and out¬
going are opened, and I didn't expect it to get to
him, which it did. I'd bought three letters, a pen,
and 20Qnl of apple juice which I made last five
days. I'd take a little sip, gulp down some water,
finishing with another sip of apple juice, not quite
convincing myself.
By Sunday evening, my excitement was buzzing around
in my head, in anticipation of my release the next
morning. I endured the Top Forty, played chess and
stayed up talking of school experiences for a couple
of hours. I slept terribly.
The next morning I got up as soon as the lights went
on, got dressed, rolled up my bedding, hid my prison
notes, and waited for my release. I said goodbye to
my cell-mates, and then went into reverse. I hadn't
expected the farewell of venom which several of the
guards gave me - obviously remembering my initiation.
"Shut your mouth Hancock, you're not out yet." "Any
complaints?" "Yes." "Right, we'll keep you in the d
day to investigate it." "Forget it, I'd rather get
out." They smiled. Far easier to co-operate. Violence
and lies and threats and contempt bear their rotten
and submissive fruits. Right up to the gate. "Fucking
get over there.'" And, then, release. Unreal freedom.
Tired. Hungry. Relieved. Thin. Roger. Chris. Home.
Breakfast.fl
12
PRISWtKFORPMCE
Shew your sol ids nty with
war resisted to prison world wiit:
POJT A CM& TDAf W5&NEA WWCE
for names faddrcjJts 1 W. • Sfc€ b
55I>awesSt. 1£L
New Catalogue also out
P.S. Next issue, 1*11 try to put my experience into
a wider context, looking at the status quo which
prisons uphold, and arguing for their destruction
and Christian non-cooperation with the legal system.
I think.
P.P.S. If you want, please write a letter to:
The Governor, HMP Winson Green, BIRMINGHAM B18,
mentioning the refusal to provide me with a vegan
diet, the threat of punishment and insinuation of
madness for not eating, and demand/ask that vegans
be given equal status with vegetarians and omnivores,
suggesting that Vegan Society membership is not and
should not be a pre-requisite and condition for
veganism. Something like that.
P.P.P.S. Write to prisoners. A card, a painting, a
letter. It makes the world of difference.
P.P.P.P.S. "Let the person without sin cast the first
stone." Is Christian discipleship compatible with
support for the legal system and its accompanying
mechanisms? Discuss.
"The wind blows where it wishes and you hear the
sound of it but you do not know where it comes from
and where it is going; so it is with everyone who is
born of the spirit." John 3:8
MA*RTIM T=ot^AkJ
hartin Foran was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment
in June 1978, following a series of burglaries in
Birmingham in September 1977, committed by a group
of black and white youths. The white youth involved
in the robberies was described as 3 feet tall, slim
built and between 18 and 20 years old. Martin was 3'—
years old, tall and thickset. One of the witnesses,
on being shown pictures of Martin, stated that thertT"
was no way that Martin could have been one of the
burglars.
Right from the moment of his arrest, Martin protested
his innocence, and whilst in prison went on hunger
strike to help bring attention to his case. As a
result of this he was transferred to Leicester Prison,
from which he escaped. After stating his case to the
national newspapers, he gave himself up to the auth¬
orities. He was then transferred co Nottingham Prison
where he conducted a 5\ week rooftop protest to high¬
light his unjust imprisonment. After this, Martin's
case was discussed in the House of Commons, but to no
avail. He was then transferred to Gartree and then
Lincoln Prison, despite the governor's promise not to
do so. He then continued his hunger strike and was
eventually released in February 1984.
After his release, Martin and his family moved to
Kingshurst, Birmingham where he set up a second¬
hand car dealer and scrap metal business. Martin
continued to protest his innoncence despite constant
hatrassment from the police. He was accused of murder¬
ing a woman, even though he was in prison at the ti«e
of the murder, and was also constantly accused of
stealing his own car.
On the 10th of Srpt-ember 1984, Martin was arrested
on two charges; one of robbery and another of
Stephen Hancock
conspiracy to rob. That day 3 youths had robbed a
publican at his pub in Birmingham of £1700, The
publican described the 3 youths as;
1 - Half-caste, West Indian male, light complexien,
age approx, 17, 5 feey 6 inches tall, dark wavy
collar length hair, carrying a 6 inch knife,
2 - West Indian male, well built, taller than 1,
wearing a balaclava and carrying a stick.
3 - unseen, but in common with 1 and 2 had a
Birmingham accent.
According to the police, Martin Foran was the
second man. As well as being considerably taller,
Martin is white and has a strong Irish accent
The result of the trial was a sentence totalling 8
years for Martin - 6 years for robbery and two for
conspiracy to rob. While he was in Winson Green
Prison, Martin started to get an anal discharge of
mucus and was sent for hospital treatment. When he
was next visited by his wife Valerie and his son
Martin, the visit was restricted to his csll. The
prison officers refused to say why so the three of
them barracaded themselves in the cell in the hope
of finding out why.
Consequntly he was transferred to Wandsworth Prison
where his health deteriorated even further. There
he was forced to take one of the prison officers
J^^tage so as to obtain hospital treatment.. It
continued, on back cover
EITHICAL ELXPLO i TATlOH?
DAN MARTIN is field officer in the Justice and Peace
Office of the (Roman Catholic) diocese of Southwark.
In 1986 the Catholic Fund for Overseas Development
(CAFOD) established formal links with Traidcraft, and
in May Dan Martin shared some misgivings
about this with the readers of ’Southwark Justice and
Peace News' in an article which we reprint here. It is
particularly timely, as increasing numbers of
organisations are following Traidcraft's example and
marketing "ethnic" Third World products in this
country through shops or catalogue sales.
TRAIDCRAFT ORGANISES the sale of goods direct from
Third World producers to consumers in this country,
by-passing transnational corporations and other
profit-seeking middle agents. Advocates of Traidcraft
^*ke the following claims about the prganisation:
i.j Traidcraft is non-profit making and therefore more of
the money goes to the producer.
12] It is ’fairer* trade, sometimes described as ’fair’ or
’just’ or 'equitable' trade.
13) There is a development education element in its
products / catalogue which encourages consumers to
think about Third World products, labour and culture.
(41 Products bought through the catalogue help
development agencies (i.e. CAFOD and Christian Aid).
(5] It encourages small cooperatives and/or supports
producers that have a .genuine concern for its workers
(e.g. Nicaragua).
As far as it goes, therefore. Traidcraft is an admirable
organisation and one which is attracting more and more
support.
CONSUMPTION
The poverty in the Third World to which Traidcraft is
responding is largely a result of 300 - 400 years of
exploitation and robbery by more powerful countries, and
it continues through existing patterns of trade and
habits of consumption. This process is fuelled by what
economists call 'effective demand', which is the
willingness and ability of people to pay for consumer
goods. Transnational corporations are very efficient at
providing the goods regardless of the consequences for
the environment and people of the Third World. 'Effective
demand’ is the fuel, and TNCs are the vehicle, for Third
World impoverishment.
However admirable its other attributes. Traidcraft
does not challenge this consumption pattern but makes
it more attractive. Through Traidcraft we can now have
our bread buttered on both sides. We can now consume
and feel good, rather than guilty. Through Traidcraft we
are assured that the producers are paid 'a fair wage,
working conditions are better, there is no "middle man",
etc.', and all this is good... but it is still a buyers'
market. It is still we in the rich first world who determine
and kind and quantity of products that are produced.
The basic relationship is not questioned. The people we
have impoverished must still work for us to earn their
daily bread. The irony is that we can only afford Third
World products because of past and present
exploitation. But why should the impoverished work for
us one second longer than they have to, however better
their conditions are?
I also think it is quite ironic (to use a mild adjective)
to see Christian Aid and now CAFOD, two organisations
working for justice and development, promoting the sale
of food and household decorations to first world
consumers from countries that do not have enough of
either.
Years ago CAFOD warned people of the hazards of
Third World child adoption schemes, but does not
Traidcraft pose the same hazards? The adopted child
whose education, meals, medicines are paid for does
receive a benefit, and it is a measure of justice, but is it
the way forward for development agencies and people
concerned for social justice? CAFOD has said ’no'
because there is a better way to help children in the
Third World. I agree with this position, and it is one which
does not challenge or question the sincerity of people
who 'adopt' Third World children.
Child adoption schemes have a danger of fostering
the wrong attitudes in both donor and recipient. It is an
active-passive relationship. The donor is charitable and
the recipient is grateful, and because of the usual racial
combination the scheme, objectively, implies that white
people are better / better off than non-white people.
Hence it sustains racial prejudices and ignores the
culpability of the donor in the creating of and
benefitting from the injustice which surrounds 'his/her
adopted' child. Also, children are members of communities:
raise the standards of community life and the children
will fare better.
continued overleaf
Stephen
Through Traidcraft small workers* collectives have
access to the pot of gold in the first world. Of course
not everything in the Third World is saleable and neither
is everyone in the Third World employable. Therefore
selection must be made on the basis of what people here
will buy. Does this not invidiously separate one part of
the community from the larger part, and advance some
members separately from others?
At the same time - like the child adoption scheme - we
can feel good, and rightly so, because we have helped
some people; we have done somet hing to alleviate
poverty. But like the adopted child, Traidcraft producers
are beholden to first world consumers, dependent on our
charity and grateful for our attention. A measure of
justice can, and often does, obscure the larger injustice.
And to say 'no* to child adoption schemes and 'yes* to
Traidcraft seems to be contradictory.
In Traidcraft*s 1985-6 catalogue Cardinal Hume writes
in support of CAFOD's formal link with Traidcraft: “For
too long we in the North have used the countries in the
South as sources of both cheap labour and natural
resources. By buying direct from small producers and
workers* co-operatives Traidcraft knows that a fair
price is paid, and that the money will go to those who do
the work." But the fact is that we are still using cheap
labour and depleting the resources of the South. More
money may be going to the producers but it is still
cheap: otherwise the goods could not be transported
half way round the world and sold here. Also the *fair
price / fair wage* paid is at or only slightly above local
rates, and these are determined by the larger social
climate. CAFOD's goal of encouraging 'self-sufficiency* is
not enhanced by links with Traidcraft, because
Traidcraft is founded on dependence. Granted it is a
modified version of what has existed before and still
does exist, and a better one, but it still relies on the old
dependent, first world / third world relationship with the
first world partner being the dominant one.
Nowhere in Traidcraft literature do I read of the need to
change and reduce first world consumption patterns,
modifying 'effective demand*. Rather, we are encouraged
to change only our source or supplier. 'Fair trade* is only
possible between equals. The relationship as it exists
now is one of gross inequality of wealth and power. What
is required is a reversal of 300 - 400 years of imperial
culture.
Yet Traidcraft lessens the exploitation, is therefore
better than transnational corporations, and should be
used as a 'halfway house' - a transitional tool - for first
world consumers on the way from full dependence on
Third World products to no, or minimal, dependence. So rf
people must buy products from the Third World - and it is
difficult not to - it is much better to buy through
Traidcraft. In some cases, as with the sale of
Nicaraguan coffee, consumption is a political as well as
an economic statement of values.
But better still is the transfer of wealth to the Third
World direct , rather than through Traidcraft which
perpetuates the view and the reality that the Third
World exists as a workshop or global shopping centre for
us consumers in the first world. These transfers can
take place through development agencies like CAFOO. and
through liberation movements and organisations in the
Third World.
Such direct transfers are the essence of justice, are
an act of restitution, and best foster the attitude that
'we are not bestowing a gift to the poor person but are
handing back to him/her what is his/hers.' (St Ambrose).
My understanding of the teaching of the Church in a
situation of such inequality as exists now is one of
voluntary poverty for the sake of sharing out of our
sustenance, rather than out of our abundance.
Traidcraft smacks of the 'work ethic* attitude whereby
the poor must earn their right to our abundance and
generosity. We dare not give without getting back in
return.
I am not prompted to write by the idea that Traidcraft
is bad, but because its supporters claim too much for it.
Traidcraft is not 'fair* trade, but fairer trade; rt is not
'free of exploitation*, but freer; it is not 'equitable
trading*, but less iniquitous trading; it is not
'partnership' but benevolence; it is a better-run
workhouse for the 'orphans, widows, stranger - the
anawim, the poor'. It is not 'radical* but liberal - which
may account for its growing popularity. •
ML THINU IK COMMON
‘'They came to Thessolonica...and paul.« . reasoned
with then out of the scriptures and some of thee
beleived•. • and of the chief women not a few.But
the '-Jews * * • moved with envy took unto them certa__
in, lewd fellows of the baser sort and gathered a
company and set the city in an uproar...crying
those that have turned the world upside down
have come hither also." Acts 17:1-9
Winstanley *s writings come from a time of great
social upheaval and economic change. Whilst
the transition from feudal to industrialised
society was happening making way for the enclo__
sure acts and industrial, cities thus leaving
ownership of land in the hands of very few
capitalists.’ The history of such groups as the
Levelers and Diggers show an attempt by cogsoc
people of England to impose their own solutions
to the problems of their time.
With the invention of the printing press and the
Bible being in English for the first time the
established church lost its monopoly on inforsatio
and interpretation was open to anyone.
This gave rise to reiigios groups such as the Bapt_
ists,Quakers and Muggletonians and also political
groups such as Levelers ,diggers, fifth monarchists
etc.Thus calling into question old ideas,attitudes,
values and beliefs in the words of Winstanley "the
old world...is running up like the parchment in the
fire." Thus this was a revolt within a revolution.^
attempt for common ownership of land and property.
..for the present state of the old world that is
running up like parchment in the fire, and wearing
away, we see proud imaginary flesh, which is the
wise serpent, rises up in flesh and gets domination
in some to rule over others, and so forces one part
of the creation, man, to be a slave to another; and
thereby the spirit is killed in both. The one looks
himself as teacher and ruler, and so is lifted up in
pride over his fellow creatures. The other looks
Winstanley sees the earth as created by the great
creator"Reason" (God) who made the earth a common
treasury for all but man abuses earth through domin_
ation particularly political/economic domination.
However he sees biblical prophecy and the light wit_
hin each person as pointing towards the inevitable
re-establishment of the earth as a common treasury.
Dave.
On April 1st 1649 some Diggers began to dig St.
George's hill in Surrey. The following is a condensed
version of a pamphlet brought out by them- It
appears in its entirity in "The Law of Freedom &
Other Writings", a Penguin edited by Christopher Hill.
The True
Levellers Standard
O R,
The Scatc of Community opened, and Prcfcntcd to the
Sons of Men.
Beginning to Plane and Manure the Warte land upon
Ccerge-HUl , in the Parilh of Walton, in the
Count)' of Surry.
upon himself as imperfect, and so is dejected in his
spirit, and looks upon his fellow creature of his
own image as lord above him.
But when the ealth becomes a common treasury again
as'it must, for all the prophesies of Scriptures and
reason are circled here in this community, and
mankind must have t^e law of righteousness once
more writ in his heart, and all must be made of
one heart and one mind.
A declaration to the powers of England and to all
the powers of the world, shewing the cause why the
common people of England have begun and gives
consent to dig up, manure and sow com upon George
Hill in Surrey; by those that have subscribed, and
thousands more that gives consent.
In the beginning of time, the great creator Reason
made the earth to be a common treasury, to preserve
beasts, birds, fishes and man, the lord that was to
govern this creation; for man had dominion given to
him, over the beasts, birds and fishes; but not one
wor d was spoken in the beginning, that one branch of
cind should rule over another.
But since human flesh ( that king of beasts ) began
to delight himself in the objects of the creation,
more than in the spirit reason and righteousness,
who manifests himself to be the indweller in the
five senses of hearing, seeing, tasting, smelling,
feeling; then he fell into blindness of mind and
weakness of heart, and runs abroad for a teacher and
ruler. And so selfish imagination, taking possess¬
ion 'of the five senses and ruling as king in the
room of reason therein, and working with covetousn¬
ess, did set up one man to teach and rule over
another; and thereby the spirit was killed and man
was brought into bondage and became a greater slave
to such of his own kind, than the beasts of the
field were to him.
And hereupon the earth (which was made to be a
commontreasury of relief to all, both beasts and
man) was hedged into enclosures by the teachers and
rulers, and the others were made into servants and
slaves: and the earth that is within this creation
made a common storehouse for all, is bought and sold
and kept in the hands of a few, whereby the great
creator is mightJLly dishonoured, as if he were a
respecter of persons, delighting in the comfortable
livlihood of some, and rejoicing in the miserable
poverty and sraits of others. From the beginning
this was not so.
Then this enmity in all lands will cease, for
none shall dare to seek a dominion over others,
neither shall any dare to kill another, nor desire
more of the earth than others, for he that will rule
over, imprison, oppress and kill his fellow
creatures, under what pretence so ever is a destroy¬
er of the creation, and an actor of the curse, and
walks contrary to the rule of righteousness: Do as
you would have others do to you; and love your
enemies, not in words but in actions.
0 thou powers of England, thought thou hast promised
to make this people a free people, yet thou hast so
handled the matter through thy self-seeking humour
that thou hast wrapped us up more in bondage, and
oppression lies heavier upon us; not only bringing
thy fellow creatures, the commoners, to a morsel of
bread, but by confounding all sorts of people by
thy government of doing and undoing.
The work we are going about is this, to dig up
George's Hill and the waste ground thereabouts and
to sow corn, and to eat our bread together by the >-
sweat of our brows.
*na uie nrst reason is this, that we may work in
righteousness and lay the foundation of making the
earth a common treasury for all, both rich and poor
that everyone that is bom in the land may be fed b
the earth his mother that brought him forth, accord
ing to the reason that rules in the creation. Not
enclosing any part into any particular han^, but al
as one man working together and feeding together as
sons of one father , members of one family; not on
lording it over another, but all looking upon each
other as equals in the creation; so that maker may
be glorified in the work of his own hands , and
that everyone may see he is no respecter of persons
but equally loves his whole creation and hates noth
ser P ent > wil ich is covetousness, branchi
ng fo*h into selfish imagination, pride, e^vy,
ypocncy, uncleanliness; all seeking the ease and
onour of flesh and fighting against the spirit
reason that made the creation; for that is the corr-
uption, the curse, the devil, the father of lies,
death and bondage, that serpent and dragon that the
creation is to be delivered from.
For it is shewed us that so long as we or any other
doth own the earth to be the peculiar interest of
lords and landlords, and not common to others as
well as them, we own the curse, and holds the creat¬
ion under bondage; and so long as we or any other
doth own landlords and tenants, for one to call the
land his, or another to hire it of him, or for one
to give hire and for another to work for hire; this
is to dishonour the work of creation.
And that...civil property is the curse is manifest
thus: those that buy and sell land, and are landl¬
ords, have got'^either by oppression or murder or
theft; and all landlords lives in the breach of the
seventh and eigh'th commandments, Thou shalt not
steal nor kill.
First by their oppression: they have by their
subtle imaginary and covetous wit got the plain-
hearted poor or younger brethren to work for them
for small wages and by thei» work have got a great
increase; for the poor by their labour lifts up
tyrants to to rule over them; or else by their
covetous wit they have out-reached the plain-
hearted in buying and selling, and thereby enriched
themselves but impoverished others: or else by their
subtle wit, having been a lifter up into places of
trust, have enforced people to pay money for a '
public use, but have divided much of it into their
private purses; and so have got it by oppression.
Then secondly for murder: they have by subtle wit
and power pretended to preserve a people in safety
by the power of the sword; and by what a large pay,
much free-quarter and other booties which they call
their own, they get much monies, and with this they
buy land and become landlords; and if once landlords
then they rise to be justices, rulers and state
govemers,<as experience shews. But all this is but
a bloody and subtle thievery, countenanced by a law
that covetousness made; and this is a breach of the
seventh commandment, Thou shalt not kill.
And likewise thirdly a breach of the eighth comma¬
ndment, Thou shalt not steal: but these landlords
have thus stolen the earth from their fellow-
creatures, that have an equal share with them by
the law of reason and creation, as well as they.
If you look through the earth, you shall see that
the landlords, teachers and rulers are oppressors,
murderers and thieves in this manner. But it was
not thus from the beginning. And this is one reason
of our digging and labouring the earth one with
another,that we might work in righteousness and lift
up the creation from bondage.
Secondly in that we begin to dig upon George’s Hill
to eat our bread together by righteous labour and
sweat of our brows, it was shewed us by vision in
dreams that that should be the place we should
begin upon.
Thirdly it is shewed us that all the prophesies,
visions and revelations of scriptures, of prophets
and apstles, concerning the calling of the Jews, the
restoration of Israel, and making of all that people
the inheriters of the whole earth, doth all seat
themselves in this work of making the whole earth a
common.treasury.
And if the earth is not peculiar to any one branch
or branches of mankind, but the inheritenve of all
; then it is free and common for all, to work
together and eat togrther.
And truly, you councillors and powers of the earth,
know this, that wheresoever there is a people thus
united by common community of livilyhood into
oneness, it will become the strongest land in the
world, for then they will be as one man to defend
their inheritence; and salvation (which is liberty
and peace) is the walla and bulwarks of that land or
city.
Whereas on the other side, pleading for property and
single interest divides the people of a land and the
whole world into parties, and is the cause of all
wars and bloodshed and contention everywhere.
...that which does encourage us to go on in this
work is this: we find the streaming out of love in
our hearts towards all,to enemies as well as friends
- we would have none live in be jery, poverty or
sorrow, but that everyone might enjoy the benefit of
his creation: we have peace in our hearts and quiet
rejoicing in our work, and filled with sweet content
though we have but a dish of roots and bread for c
our food.
The common people are filled with good words from
pulpits and council tables, but no good deeds; for
HtIJJI
m '' 'V
'bi'istfiiiijfiiiiii
GR€€A AAARCHV
they wait and wait for good and for deliverences,
but none comes. While they wait for liberty, behold
greater bondage comes instead of it; and burdens,
oppressions, task masters, from sessions, lawyers,
bailiffs of hundreds, committees, improprieters,
clerks of peace and courts of justice (so called)
whip the people. Oh you A-dams of the earth, you
have rich clothing, full bellies, have your honours
and and ease, and you puff at this; but know this
thou stout-hearted Pharaoh, that the day of judge¬
ment is begun, and it will reach to thee ere long.
Jacob hath been very low, but he is rising, and will
do the worst thou canst; and the poor people whom
thou oppresses shall be the saviours of the land.
For the blessing is rising up in them, and thou
shalt be ashamed.
...'.'Honour thy Father and Mother": thy father,
which is the spirit of community, that made all
and dwells in all; thy mother, which is the earth,
that brought us all forth: that as a true mother
loves all her children. Therefore do not hinder
the mother earth from giving all her children
suck, by enclosing it into particular hands, and
holding up that cursed bondage of enclosure by thy
power.
And then thou wilt repent of thy theft, in maintai¬
ning the eighth commandment, by stealing the land
as I say from thy fellow-creatures, or younger
brothers; which thou and all thy landlords have and
do live in the breach of that commandment.
Thus we have discharged our souls in declaring the
cause of our digging upon George’s Hill in Surrey,
that the great council and army of the land may take
notice of it, that there is no intent of tumult or
fighting, but only to get bread to eat with the
sweat of our brows; working together in righteousn¬
ess and eating the blessings of the earth in
peace. .and any of you that are the great ones
of the earth..this conquest over thee shall be
got, not by sword or weapon, but by my Spirit, saith
the Lord of Hosts.®___ _
w
16
JANIE REVIEWS JCNE,
Real anarluivt macs
Green Anarchist 50p per issue
Magdalen Rd, Oxford OX 41 RP
Very strong on thir
magazine is fairly
Salt, but Green An
has information ab
slightly more viole
what it used to be,
reading, if only for
Processed World $15
mail, $7-$10 in USA
1829, San Francisco
Difficult to get
retail outlets,
american interest
magazine is chiefly
work is and how nast
in the office. Reco
has ever had a bor
uncaring company.
E ach magazine foe
a, the one I h
.alth, for example.
from 19
Glass War £1.75 for next six issues from:
Po box 467 ,London E8 3QX or most normal
anarchist / radical sources. This magazine
is perhaps best described as the sun for
anarchists. It advocates overthrow of the
‘d w
orld ri
ghts, this
' si
milar to
Pinch of
tare
hist is
fo
r pagans,
iout
festiva
1 s
and is
nee
orient
a t
ed. Not
b
ut still
essential
t h
e herbs
CO
1umn.A
f 0
r 4 issu
es
surface
f r
om : 41
S
utter St.
CA
94104, USA
in
this c
ou
nty from
and
mostly
covering
top
ics, th
is
radical
CO
ncerned
w
it h what
y i
t really
i
s to work
mme
nded for
a
nyone who
ing
job with
a large
use
s on a
different
ave
here (
no
.20 ) on
state by
violence
people.
classes.A
means of mass working
against the police and
Not for the timid or the
the
this
always
mornitig
in the
1±U±1 £1 Per year sub. contact 84b
chapel High Street, London El 7QX
Brought out not often enough
anarchist-communist federation,
interesting discussion paper is
worth a read if you wake up one
feeling theoretical. Articles
current issue include a review of Maryl»in
French s Beyond Power" and a piece bn
Marx, Lenin and Work. this magazine is
well thought out, convincing and worth
reading.
J be • M C,F * alS0 brin 9 out a more
accessible paper called ’ Liberation 1 -
watch out for them at demos.B
~ A.
COED
-r^n- 1 m ■■ W mkm* 0 u t ' or them at demos.®
j|ffj <i mw
SUWpSEDiY THE LCTim PAGE BUT ITI>1PN’TQUITE
hie letter's page is a bit dispersed - J„ K +ir,.= <= „„ I t WUKA WW I
-_is ietter s page is a bit dispersed - Justin's is on page
•. Franks below, and Jeremy's on page 19. Ve meant to put
lext^ssue Andy Pster ' bUt Spa ° e Went glua P f " GO >
Letters, we love them. Even just hellos. If you want
them published try to make it clear - write some-
thing like FOR PUBLICATION" at the top (or write
’not for publication" if you don't). Tell us what
you re up to, share concerns, news or whatever.
CVTnnnOCXXXXDCXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXTO
Santa Lucia
Dear Stephen
Dear Sisters and Brothers
Thankyou for the copies of " A Pinch of Salt "
which I have passed on to a couple of other
^Qrcha - United Mystics here. The magasine is
ry thought provoking and there is a lot to
comment on.
There are many anarchists and many Christians who
state that Christianity is impossible, that there
are things in anarchism which are incompatible
with Christianity and vice versa. Yet, if my
memory serves me corrc.tly it was none other than
Kropotkin who, writing for the Encyclopedia
Britannica ( 1904 edition? .) listed Christian
Anarchism as one of the four types of anarchism,
the others being anarcho-communism, anarcho-
collectivism and anarcho-mutua1ism.
The dogma of " No Gods, No Masters " which is
waved at Christiananarchists isn't very convinc¬
ing as a political theory, no slogan ever is.
It’s an oversimplification. Christians don’t
have gods - they have one God. Of course many
Christians have masters of one sort or another
but this is against the teaching of Jesus.
Matthew 23 quotes Jesus as being against
Masters and Teachers - verses 8 to 12. ( but
you don’t need me to tell you that do you)
there is one problem for Anarchris-
not^been sufficiently well defined,
of " A Pinch of Salt ” it would seem
form of Quakerism which has grown
up with the Peace Movement, perhaps with a Catholic
Worker popping up here and there. .Am I right in
1007, non-violent
stand on Liberation
thinking that Christianarchy is
pacifist ? If so, where do )__
Theology and Christian participation in 3rd world
armed liberation movements. And what about past
phases of ChristianarcAiy ? Would you include Munzer
and the German anabaptists who took over Munster
within your ancestry ? The Quakers before they
became pacifists ?
I think this is a real problem. We can bombard each
other with quotes from the Bible or from Great Anar¬
chist Heroes, about what is right or wrong, but it
doesn t get us anywhere and the anarchist movement
is divided up enough already. As an Anarchist
Interested in Religion and Spirituality I think
that it's necessary to go beyond texts and look to
the spirit within each one of us to guide us. If we
can get to the truth through Zen or Tao or Acid then
let's get to it.
I admit this is a bit ill defined and maybe begs
more answers than it offers. Perhaps one day I will
be clearer too, and write you a proper article. In
the meantime keep up the Good News,
Love, Peace and Liberty,
Frank.
"The Kingdom of God is not coming with signs to
be observed;nor will they say;look,here it is or
there it is for behold the Kingdom of God is among
you"Luke 17:20
For me however
tianity : it's
From the pages
to be a modern
17
A rtw &WW ANI> 1'AHPHLtrf
u The arrogance of uncohtested power ",by Laurens
Otter, describes the case of Hilda Murrell and dis¬
cusses the way the state abuses power. If you
have the stomach for a tale involving narrow minded
country folk, fascist^ and murder, then write to
Wrekin Libertarians, College farm
house, Wellington Salop
Published sixty years ago," Pacifism and Class War "
remains a compelling statement on revolutionary
nonviolence. Written by A.J.Muste, it still has
something to say to the peace movements through¬
out the industrial democracies. Hence the reissue
by Ploughshares press. Available from PoS address,
price 35p+ large SAE (16 pages
Are there such things as slaves in the world today?
According to the Anti-Slavery Society fir the Pro¬
tection of human rights, there are 200,000,000 world
wide, which is over three 3 times the population of
the U.K. To read more about the facts of modem
slavery get the Society's " Anti-S1avery Reporter "
£3.50 from 180 Brixton road, London SW9 6AT.®
Are you an adventist, anarchist, apocalyptic,
communitarian, millenarian, republican, revolu¬
tionary, student of nuclear doomsday- or just a
plain visionary like the oridinary English people?
So was John Bunyan. " John Bunyan and the search
for an English conscience " transforms the orthodox
image of Bunyan as a pious classic. It takes him
out of the world of Sunday schools and exams and
puts him in a milieu of apocalyptic, millenarian
-even magical - beliefs and events. No disrespect
is intended to Bunyan! On the contrary this book's
argument is that such ideas were the common stock
ordinary people and their leaders. By John Nichol¬
son, available from BM BOZO London WC1N 3XX price
£2.40 plus p&p. (114 pages)#
A confession and other reliqous
by Leo Tolstoy (Penguin,1987 £3.95)
This recently published new translation of
some of Tolstoy's hard to get hold of minor
works. The 'Confession' of the title is a
description of Tolstoy's harrowing story of
near suicide and the start of his
redemption, in his own humanistic brand of
Christianity. The rest of the works in the
300 page book expand on his spiritual
thought. Even if you don't agree with all
that he says, this book is a very moving
record of one remarkable man's attempt to
find, and live by, the truth.#
writings
One of the wildest and most crazy groups to exist
within the history of Christian Anarchy were the
Ranters. Famed among the Ranter;was Abiezer Coppe.
So rush out and steal a copy of " Abiezer Coppes :
Selected writings" Ed. by A.Hopton. Or alternatively
write to Aporia Press, 308 Camberwell New Road,
London SE5 ORW sending £2.95. Full review "the
plagues of God fell into my pocket'next issue.®
r (j^
From Jeremy: "this is something I've cooked, and I
think it passes as vegan. The quantities are some¬
what suspect".......•
.ERSATZ GROUNDNUT
palmfuls of
onion
2 tomatoes
palmful peas
carrot
STEW.
lentils (or TVP or beans or .....}
1 knife's worth of marmite/yeast extract
1 knife's worth peanut butter (this is the essential
part)
Chilli powder/Curry powder (optional)
Anything else you want to throw in
fresh; p c s si11 y
a more attract-
Chop up the onion and carrot; add to lentils anc
boil (How much water? - enough)
Add chopped up tomatoes, or eat them
substitute tomato paste (can give it
ive colour).
Add peas, curry powder, yeast extract, peanut butter.
Stop boiling when: too hungry to wait any longer
the consistency o.f the stew looks
a ttractive
there is a smell of burning. It
should still be OK.
Eat with boiled (brown) rice, or whatever you wish
to try it with.
Have fun. Yours in hope/Christ/God
Pancakes
To make batter, add equal amounts of soya flour arc
wholemeal flour, then mix throughly with soya nilk
until the mixture is smooth and lump free. Heat up
a frying pan with jsut under a tablespoon of vege*
able oil in it, tip in a dollup on mixture ( enoug -
to make a six inch diameter circle ) wait a aonert
and then stop the pancake from sticking by poking a
fishslice underneath. Turn or toss to cook other
side, and when it is done, fold up with jam or isar-
mite in it yum yum.
P.S. A splodge of tahini and a pinch of salt ran ne
added to the mix. Long live substitutionary vegar—sr!
The promised article on veganism is simmering on Hv»
back stove, and will be served at a later date.
Meanwhile.
THE VEGAN CHRISTIAN NETWORK
' /an intxo-
/ Write to
Lesley for details: 10 Brook CourV^^lays Lane,
Stratford, LONDON E15, or phone// 534 7124.
In the meantime we're compilin /Yx directory of
vegan Christians, so do writ//r> Lesley if you wane
Dearie, another LET1EK
A basic tenet of anarchy, no God, no masters? No
allegiance to anyone or anything that is set on a
higher (moral, spiritual, or power) plane than one's
self? Thus no basic human rights, no right/privelege
to complain about injustice - surley? Since to do so
is to assume that at least some people (oppressors/
communists/anybody I don't like) must acknowledge
the existence of something higher than themselves,
even if it is just the realisation that they are
not the only human around.
To me, anarchy is, in part at least, the awareness
of a distinction between power and authority. To
obey, to follow, authority is one thing. If the
parachute instructor recommends not jumping without
a parachute, you can ignore the command; but would
you? That’s authority. You obey, follow, owe alleg¬
iance not through fear but because you recognise the
existence of a greater knowledge that will benefit
you. I believe in God, and believe that following my
ial to me and those around me. My belief is based on
faith; you can choose to have a different faith,
that there is no God. But to say that to believe in
a greater good excludes me from being an anarchist -
whether I choose that label or not - does not
logically follow.
In effect, you are saying ’’Follow me; for through my
unbelief lies the road to true anarchy”. So much for
no leaders.
On the question of basic human rights - which I
presume you deny the existence of - I would argue
they do not exist. They are priveleges. With my
belief, I claim they are God-given priveleges -
such as the right to life. They can be denied by
people/society, but they do not cease to exist <
because of that. Without a God to pass them on ;
externally to us, these "rights” are discovered/
declared by people. And what they have given, they
can take away. Yours
Dudley
God's laws (or at least trying to) will be benefic- I i l | |V |~| j ere my Dudlc
LOflK AT AUTORETHlfKS HAPPENING Di J ANI/ r CAGES
DIARY DIARY DIARY DIARY DIARY DIARY DIARY DIARY DIARY Order a bundle of "Pinchp<;“ +n =.n _ = ln , K „„ „ „
a bundle of "Pinches" to sell - 5,10,15,20. Sell them
March 18-20: "SUBVERTING STUDENTS" weekend for students at next to the SVP, outside your church, inside on top send
shelves of
with Brum
to friends, take to demos, place a few on the
your local Christian bookshop. Get in touch
address.
To gain confidence
Aldermaston Demo. A
in salt selling - join us at the
the New University - 24 South Road, Hockley, BIRMINGHAM B18
(sounds a familiar address)
^*i.l 1st - 4th: CND March to Aldermaston - demo on the
w cer Monday (sell Pinch - get in touch if interested)
April 5th - 9th: Student Christian Movement National
Congress in Glasgow - SCH 186 St .Paul’s Rd., Balsall heath,
BIRMINGHAM B12
April 30th: Meal of the Vegan Christian Network - see
opposite page
May 1st: Sunday lunch for any interested London (and
further if you want) "Pinch of Salt" readers, followed by
look at material for next "Pinch" and discussion of ways
forward &c. Contact Lesley - see opposite page under
Vegangelical Cookery Corner.
May 2nd:APF procession around Molesworth.
July 16/17: Gathering in field at Brotherhood Church,
Stapleton. More info next "Pinch" (will also try to do a
little piece an the Brotherhood Church)
July 24-31: Nonviolence with Dan Berrigan - London, contact address, and we’ll arrange a planning meeting
FoR - 40-46 Harleyford Road, Vauxhall, London SE11
I m hoping to help set up a nonviolence centre/community
sometime in the Autumn - a resource for Christian
anarchism-pacifism, Christian pacifism, and pacifism/active
nonviolence. If you're atall interested, do get in touch with
me in Brum.Stephen. A
There are back issues of no.s 2,5,7 & 8 available upon
request. Also, copies of Ammon Hennacy's “The Book of
Ammon" available for £6,50 Cincl p&p). And badges. A
Several people are interested in a Christian Hunt Sab - if
there are any more out there, please get in touch via APoS
Don't forget Greenbelt August Bank holiday.I
THOSE WHO PUT THIS ISSUE OUT .
Stephen is an ali
whom the Jesus
tea youth
People like to
Lesley likes
flowery materials,
apart from that is
indescribable. She
also lives with
Harold and Stan
ho. In his spare time
Jamie likes
vegan
biscuits
-please
send him
some.
As you may easily notice, "A Pinch of
Salt" is very male dominated. This is not the state of the
magazine we want, maybe it's a reflection on the appeal of
Christian Anarchism - more likely, self-perpetuation. So,
please, especially women, get involved - send in graphics,
poems, articles, come to the open meeting on May 1st in
London (see diary). Tell us what you're up to, what your
ideas of Christian Anarchism are, how it affects your life.
Put your name down as a contact in the next "Pinch"
and sell the mag at Aldermaston, or whatever.^
L13TEN YOU
RICH PEOPLE....
ua ve, our resident biblical
scholar and part-time mystic,
lives in Welwyn
Garden City, and
translates the
Bible from the
original Good
News Version
irM
l HC * JOCKS
In the wake of the Stock Market Crash, "A Pinch'
has embarked upon cautious recovery. Going to press Xa£t
issue we had £197.60 (£192.70 of which is a loan from me).
That issue, including mailings, set us back £197.40. We
received about £170 in donations and about £20 worth of
stamps (sending stamps is a very good idea - thanks). So,
there's roughly £175 in the bank before going to press with
this one. As it's a bumper issue, we're running off 1000, so
the next printing bill's gioing (going) to be a good £270
plus stamps. Ve rely on your donations. So, "Listen you rich
people, weep and wail because of the misery which is coming
upon you", or, alternatively, fill in the slip below.
love and mammon
Stephen
I am
home
address so we
.I live at (students please
don't lose you in holidays)..
give
.I enclose a donation of £./I can't
afford one/1 don't want to give one/1 enclose some stamps
(Cheques payable to "A Pinch of Salt")
19
wrrrrrrrrr
rrrrrrrrrr
rrrrrrrrrr^
any letters, but mine from Winson Green got
and “lifted my spirits up“.
All the info in this piece is taken from
in BLACK FLAG* S
. 'rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr?
rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr f
y
continued from page thirteen
is because of this that Martin has been sentencec to
another six years in jail. /hen his wife next
visited him, Martin was kept behind a screen, and
was refused water despite his sore cracked lips,
and was not- allowed to receive any wedding anniv¬
ersary cards.
Shortly afterward he was transferred to Wilton Pris¬
on where he had a colostomy operation. 3 weeks
after the operation he was badly beaten up by the
prison officers, making his medical condition even
worse.
Martin was then transferred to Parkhurst for 1*
months and was then sent to Long Lartin Prison.
There his medical condition worsened with the ad¬
vert of running sores in his groin and an infection
of his colostomy.
In August 1937 he was transfered back toParkhurst*
His condition has improved but the sores and infect
ions are still causing him greatdifficultlies.
Martin was due for release in August 1989 but this
has been put back until 1995 due to the outcoce of
his latest trial.
The severity of the additional sentence of 6 years
can only be regarded as sheer revenege. It is now
more important than ever to step up the pressure tx>
obtain Martin's release from prison.
Send letters to:Martin Foran,c51796, RMP Parkhurst
Newport, Isle of Wight,P03Q 5NX
or send letters of protest to the Governor at the
above address. For a time Martin wasn’t being allowed ^
to him
"V
T 1
V
V
V
T
V
V
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
p
r
p
r
r
r
r
a piece
£ t*5
O Q> (D
£ OQ M
(D c+
fcT* ^ l—L.
£* to
Cd cn
oq a c
_ O (D
O ”
9 cn
tr a
hoc
o t) ^
S tephen
SOUTH AFRICA
Land where rights of many
Are diced to feed privilege
Of the few.
Where sliced oppression
Praises God of rubber bullet.
And CS qas hanqs fringe
Of polluted rain on changeless -
Land where blood splashed sunset
Rests in twilight sleep
Till light from fresh dawn
Cl9ses out aching pain
Of scattered flesh
Bleeding its tears behind
Drawn curtain of night.
Land where prophets of State
Crown the anti Christ.
Land where proud are exulted
Poor humbled
And their grief dismissed.
Land where dispossessed kneelirr
Beneath cloud of unseeing aocress
Know change emerges from below
And surges into being.
Land where raw suffering
rough edge of the Cross
crucifixion
r
r
r
r
r
'T
T
T
T
IT
theclov.
Pat Isiorbo
'T
"T
X
T
T
T
"T
X
T
rr
Printed by Dot
on recycled pai